Backyard Bot HQ

Editorial Policy: How We Pick, Rate and Update

The rules, short version

We never

  • Take money from a brand for a pick, a higher rank or a softer review
  • Give star scores or points out of 10
  • Show Amazon prices, which change too fast to stay right
  • Invent owners, quotes or numbers
  • Show a page to a brand before it goes live

We always

  • Tie every pick to a kind of yard or pool
  • Say who should skip each model
  • Date every price and credit it to the brand
  • Fix mistakes in the open and note what changed
  • Update a page first when a model is recalled

Our picks are ours. No brand can pay to be recommended, to be ranked higher or to have a weakness left out, and we don’t publish sponsored reviews. This page explains how we choose models, how we judge them, how often pages change and what happens when we get something wrong.

Brands can’t buy a recommendation

We earn money when you buy through some of our links (the affiliate disclosure has the details). That income never decides a pick.

In practice that means a few firm rules:

  • No sponsored posts, paid placements or “featured partner” slots inside a review or a best-of list.
  • A brand with an affiliate program doesn’t get ranked above one without a program. Some brands we cover, such as Dolphin, don’t offer an affiliate program we’ve been able to join, and they still get recommended when they’re the right call.
  • Commission rates don’t change verdicts. If a model with a lower payout fits your yard better, it’s the pick.
  • Brands don’t see pages before they go live and can’t ask for edits. They can point out a factual error, and we’ll fix it if they’re right, the same as for anyone else.
  • If a brand ever sends us a free product or pays for anything, we’ll say so plainly on the page concerned.

How we match a pick to your yard or pool

There’s no single best robot mower, and anyone who names one without asking about your lawn is guessing. Every recommendation on this site is tied to a situation.

For robot lawn mowers, the deciding factors are usually these:

  • Lawn size, in square feet or acres, against the mower’s rated area.
  • Slope, in both percent and degrees. A rating of 45% sounds steep, but it’s about 24 degrees, and the slope converter does that math for you.
  • Sky view and trees. RTK satellite mowers lose their fix under heavy canopy or close to tall walls, while camera and LiDAR models handle shade differently.
  • How the yard is split. Separate front and back lawns, narrow side passages and driveways between zones change which mower works.
  • Total cost, including any RTK reference station, subscriptions, blades and the warranty length.

For pool robots and solar skimmers, we look at pool type (in-ground or above-ground), size, shape, surface, steps and benches, whether you need wall and waterline cleaning, battery runtime, and how easy the robot is to lift out and empty.

Then we say who should buy each model and who should skip it. Every product page carries at least one “skip it if” line, because knowing when not to buy is half the value of a review.

What “rated” means here

We don’t hand out star scores or made-up points out of 10. A star rating can’t tell you whether a mower will cope with your 30-degree bank or your oak trees, so we don’t pretend it can.

Instead, each verdict is a plain sentence naming the model and the yard or pool it suits, with the brand’s US list price and the month it was checked. When a model doesn’t live up to its spec sheet, we say so.

We never invent owners, quotes or numbers.

Prices you can trust to be dated

Every price on the site is the brand’s own US list price, shown with the month and year it was checked. If the brand’s store has a sale on, we may add that too, dated and credited to the brand. We don’t show Amazon prices, since they change too often to stay accurate on a page. To see today’s Amazon price, use the “Check price on Amazon” button.

How often pages are updated

Robot mowers and pool robots change every season, so pages get regular checks:

  • Buying guides and comparisons are reviewed before each mowing season and each pool season, and again when a brand launches a model that changes the picks.
  • Pre-launch pages for announced models are updated when US pricing, ship dates or FCC approval are confirmed.
  • Fix guides are revised when a firmware update or a new support article changes the steps.
  • Prices are rechecked whenever a page is updated and always carry their check date.

Each page shows the date it was last updated, so you can see at a glance how fresh it is.

Corrections

If we get a fact wrong, we fix it quickly and openly. Small errors, such as a typo in a spec, are corrected in place. If a correction changes a recommendation or a key number, we add a short note at the end of the page saying what changed and when.

Product recalls get priority. If a model we recommend is recalled, we update the page as soon as we learn about it.

Found something that’s off? Tell us through the contact page or email hello@backyardbothq.com. Please include the page and the detail that’s wrong. A link to the source helps.

Who is responsible

Shaker Abu Drais edits Backyard Bot HQ and is responsible for every page on it. You can read more on the about page.

What a verdict looks like

A real one, from our Mammotion LUBA 3 AWD 3000 review. Every review has the same parts.

Mammotion LUBA 3 AWD 3000

$2,799 3Mammotion US list price, Nov 21, 2026

1Best for: Hilly lawns up to 0.75 acre split into several zones

2Skip it if: Your lawn is flat and open, or the soil stays soft

4No stars, no score out of 10

Read the full review
  1. Who it's for. A yard or pool you can picture, not a vague "great value".
  2. Who should skip it. All 94 reviews on the site have one, so you can rule a model out fast.
  3. A dated price. The brand's own US list price and the date we checked it. For today's Amazon price, use the Amazon button.
  4. No score. A star rating can't tell you if a mower will handle your slope or your trees, so we don't give one.

How fresh the pages are

Every page shows the date it was last checked. Here's the whole site at a glance.

114guides, reviews and fixes
114checked in the last 30 days
Nov 21latest update

Recently checked

When pages get a full review

JanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDec
Buying guides and mower picksBefore mowing season
Pool robot picksBefore pool season
Launches, firmware fixes and recallsAs they happen

Spotted something wrong?

Tell us the page and the detail that's off. A link to the brand's page helps.

  • A small slipA typo or a wrong spec is fixed in place, and the page's update date changes.
  • A changed pick or key numberWe fix it and add a short note at the end of the page saying what changed and when.
  • A recallIt goes to the front of the queue. The page is updated as soon as we learn about it.